Hi Bobby, Couldn't suppress a grin when I read your "windows" remark...) Here's what I think:
In a slick, graphic and colourful shot, like the drops on the CD, I'd consider the reflection of the windows redundant, as they do not fit with the theme and the atmosphere / effect of the photo.
In this case, where a more natural surface is used, with it's intrinsic flaws and texture, and a more even colour, the reflection of the windows add a bit of tension, as well as liven up the image, and have therefore a better fit in this composition. Without the window reflection, the drops and, indeed, the entire scene would've also been stripped of the dimensions in it, and be more abstract in its appearance. See what I mean?
I like this one, as it has a fit with the previous ones, but is entirely different in it's "look and feel". Good job, and expertly lit, too. Please continue with this experiment!
Cheers,
Hugo
0
B:)liana {K:30945} 6/30/2004
well what can I tell. I love them! Kisses, Biliana
0 
) Here's what I think: 
{K:75282} 6/30/2004