|
|
derin deniz
{K:3544} 10/14/2009
|
very very nice work.
|
|
|
|
Marcio Janousek
{K:32538} 6/22/2009
|
Very nice..
Congrats.
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/20/2009
|
that's my point Soumya da....portrait akta vast area. Ami je example gulo upload korlam ogulo I guess tomar bhalo lage na. Amar besh bhalo lage..tai ami chesta korechi anar orokom akta. Fortunately it got highlighted. Ebar criticism er opp amar kothatao to sunte hobe! Jani ami onek chotokhato photographer ar onek kom theory etc jani ba follow kori. Anyway....what I ask for is honest critique.....from beginning...and I will continue to do so till the end. But opposite ta sotti noi setai barbar promanito hochche. No more comments pls.
|
|
|
|
Avi
{K:70138} 6/20/2009
|
Soumya,
isssshh, 'arguing' bole 'quarelling' er scope take katiye dili ??? ami bhabchhilam shonibar shokal shokal luchi ar bonde kheye tui komor bedhe jhogra korte nemechhish :):):)
anyway, ami toke alada mail korechhi. tobe sheta tor tcs id te chole gechhe. eikhane ebar amra tinjonei khanto diy !
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/20/2009
|
avi da,
aami jani na tumi keno ebhabe suru korle. but i was arguing only, not quarreling. read my earlier posts, u will always find words like "plz". tumi jodi criticism ta k "jhhogra" mone koro tahole amar mone hoy amar chup kore jawai bhalo.
UF e etai amar last criticism session. sory for everything to both avi da and anindya!
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/20/2009
|
tor award pawa niye aami khubi khushi. award always makes one more confident about own work.
anyway, toke aami koyekta simple example dekhachchhi. these r photos clicked by people like me and u. avi dao dekho. these r very basic examples of portrait photography yet they r beautiful. and they support my point also.
http://www.usefilm.com/image/1528768.html
http://www.usefilm.com/image/1528694.html
http://www.usefilm.com/image/1528481.html
http://www.usefilm.com/image/1528128.html
|
|
|
|
|
Avi
{K:70138} 6/20/2009
|
Soumya ami jani na tui keno byaparta ekta jhograr dike tene niye jachhish. anyway, let's take this offline.
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/20/2009
|
avi da,
tomake bojhha mushkil karon tumi bhison contradictory sab byapar bolchho. etokkhon UF er sab award pawa chhobi diye example dichchhile, now u r saying UF e award byapar tar ullekh biroktijonok.
sorry i couldn't understand ur point. may be thats my fault, i am more used to understand simple logic only. tumio plz kichhu mind koro na.
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/20/2009
|
arekta dilam. Onar hoito 200 tar modhdhe 3-4 te erokom....similar typer portrait onar onno bhabeo ache....tobe ai style ta amar bhison bhalo legechilo bole dekhlam. ar amar wide lens gulo fast noi...tai ichche thakleo ami onek somoy dof ante parina....
|
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/20/2009
|
arekta
|
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/20/2009
|
soumya da....uf e award ami nai pete pari. peyechi bole bhalo legeche setao bolechi tomae...karon amar atleast bangali ra jara peyeche tader modhdhe baje chobi award peyechee se rokom kom i legeche. amar cheye bhalo portrait ekhane nischoi ache. tobe tomae jeta bolchilam tar koyekta dilam dakho..ei gulo amar personally khub bhalo lage....
|
|
|
|
|
|
Avi
{K:70138} 6/20/2009
|
kokhonoi na.
but this photo is an excellent portrait for me. tor kachhe na-i hote pare. end of discussion.
ar ekta kotha: UF er award pawa ta ami jani na kono karone KPC-r oneke naak sitke dekhe. tar karon onek oga chhobi award peye jaay .. but that can NEVER undermine a really good photo.
tai amar kachhe ei UF er award byapar tar ullekh ektu biroktijonok. kichhu mind korish na.
|
|
|
|
Supriyo R. Sarkar
{K:7582} 6/20/2009
|
CONGRATULATION!!!!
DARUN HOYECHE.
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/20/2009
|
avi da,
ekhaneo same problem. OOF hoye jawa body part ta besh distracting. ei chhobi tateo same problem. mukh ta aaro close crop kora uchith chhilo.
aar ekta byapar - UF e ekta award pawa chhobi kei ki tumi benchmark hisebe mone koro!!???
|
|
|
|
|
Avi
{K:70138} 6/20/2009
|
Soumya, BG-r dof ta onek beshi. Kintu mukh ar body-r modhye ekta dof achhe, sheta tui keno dhorte parli na jani na. Body ta motei in sharp focus noy. Look at her shoulders, especially her right (your left). Ei subtle byapar gulo dhorte na parle ami ar ki bolbo bol..
Ar tui bolechhish je amar ei example ar Anindya'r chhobita alada. Because amar chhobitay subject more glamorous, ei to ? achha, baad de.. eta dekh:
http://www.usefilm.com/image/550325.html
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/20/2009
|
tui bhul bujhhli. tui amar purono sab kota post abar por. aami toke ekbar o kintu DOF bodlanor katha bolini. all i wanted to say is cropping out the OOF area. thats all.
anyway kata. amar mone hoy tui ei chhobi tay aar critic dewa pochhondo korchhis na.
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/20/2009
|
bujhlam tumi tomar jaega theke norbe na tai ar further o niye bolbo na, karon amio amar jaega theke norbo na...atleast on dof. baki roilo improvement korar jaegae....seta akta ami nijei jani..pechoner part ta...arekta nilu da bolechilo.
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/20/2009
|
avi da, tomar example tomar katha k contradict korchhe. tomar dewa chhobi tay model er jotota ta included, purotai sharp focus e, only BG oof. that's my only point till i started arguing here. thanks for making my point stronger.
anindya, tor dewa chhobi tar sathe avi dar chhobir compare hoyna. duto diff genre. but still, portrait is the parent genre where u have to keep the complete part of the model in focus. OOF area na thakai banchhonio.
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/20/2009
|
tor ei chhobi ta amar khubi bhalo legechhe. excellent drishti meye tar chokhe. kintu still amar mote jeta scope of improvement chhilo, bolechhi.
tui intimate portrait er katha bolli tai likhlam. tor ei chhobi ta intimate portrait hoyni, seta tui google e srch diye intimate portrait er prochur example dekhlei bujhhte parbi. even aami j crop ta korechhi setao j intimate hoyechhe ta noy. but closer.
|
|
|
|
|
Avi
{K:70138} 6/20/2009
|
Soumya, ami jani na tui kon discussion porechhish. Ar photo.net er discussion je be-all and end-all erokom kichhu-o ami konodin porini :P
Tui je portrait bolchhish ami sheta bujhechhi. Kintu ami je portrait bolchhi tui sheta bujchhish na. ekta udahoron dekh:
http://www.usefilm.com/image/1376731.html
This is Hasselblad + 80mm prime. Ei chhobi tolar jonnyo ami 10 mile hete jete raaji achhi. Dekh, eta personal pochhonder byapar.. thik bhul kichhu nei.
Avi da.
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/20/2009
|
ami etae matha katta chaini soumya da. intimate mane ki sudhui mathatai thakbe frame e byas? photo.net thik ache...flickr niye ami bishes matha ghamai na. Tumi steve mccurry r portrait boita dekho..ei rokom style er onek ache onar. tomar ai chobita temon pochondo hoini bujhlam...seta hotei pare. kintu nicher oi portion ami crop korte thik chaina.
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/20/2009
|
avi da, 0 er kono mulyo nei :-)
portrait er perspective, dof, aperture control niye aami anek discussion porechhi photo.net e aar flickr e (chaile link o dite pari). segulo niye bhabna chinta korechhi bolei egulo bolchhi. fast lens niye wide open kore portrait kintu keui tole na. sabai f4/5.6 moton rakhe aar DOF er jonno oof j part ta hobe seta k frame ei rakhe na. ekhane setai aami point out korechhi.
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/20/2009
|
tor point bujhhechhi. tui jodi chokh ta kei prominence dite chas tahole aaro intimate portrait hote hoto. eta intimate hoyni. tui opore space chherechhis, niche space chherechhis. nice oof body part kichhu add korchhe ki? tahole keno frame er modhye rekhechhis? tor point kintu tor ei composition k contradict korchhe. tui j point ta bolchhis, seta k support korbe ei framing ta...
|
sample |
|
|
|
|
Avi
{K:70138} 6/19/2009
|
hyan, tui better explain korechhish. soumya onno dhoroner portrait er kotha bhebe bolchhe, ar ami onno dhoroner. tor ei portrait ta kintu amar dhoroner modhye pore, tai ami-y thik. :)
soumya, tor sathe ami 1000000000000000000000000000000 bar disgaree korchhi. Ar '0' niye khelbi ???? :)
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/19/2009
|
thanks Avida.....han dekhi jodi bakigulo bhorte pari :)
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/19/2009
|
soumya da eta ami aktu disagree korlam. Tumi jeta bolecho setao kichu khetre thik abar avi dar tao thik. dof control ta kintu intimate/close portrait e expected.....tumi jodi karor mukher specialty bar kore ante chao..tahole ki dof use korbe na.....eta jodi sadhu hoto ganja tanche ba kono old lok jar mukher texture tao bhison prominent hoya dorkar, tahole ami hoito eta f8 e tolar chesta kortam. kintu eta slight opor theke newa shot....ar main impact ta ai meyetar chokhe imo. kichu portrait e subject sundor pose diye thake..emon ta hole take bg theke alada kore dekhano seta thik. kintu jodi subject tai amar frame ta puro dokhol kore rakhe...tahole ami to dof use kore specialty ta bojhabar chesta kortei pari tai na?
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/19/2009
|
100000 times disagree with avi da. DOF emon rakhte hobe portrait e jate subject er jotota niye portrait hochchhe tar theke BG k alada kora jay. subject er kichhu ta focused, kichhuta out of focused - eta portrait e kakhonoi desirable noy.
sei jonnoi keu mediumformat+prime lens e f1.8 e portrait tole na, around f4 rakhe.
|
|
|
|
|
Avi
{K:70138} 6/19/2009
|
1000 times disagree with Soumya. shorir ta in focus-e thakle chhobita darato-i na. bhalo portrait-er ekta part holo dof .. emon level e hobe je shudhu mukh ta beriye thakbe. Er jonne loke hajar hajar dollar khorcha kore medium format+prime lens kene.
Ei jonnei boli landscape dekhe dekhe shob kichhu sharp dekhar chahida toiri hoye jaay, jeta bhul.
Thik jemon Soumya-r dewa oi flickr-er link ta jekhane HCB-r ekta chhobite loke 'unsharp', 'out-of-focus' koto kichhu bolechhe..
anyway, bottomline is, ekta ghor bhorlo. ar 5 ta baki ;)
Congrats !!
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/19/2009
|
thanks krishnendu.....tomar chobitao dekhalm. khub bhalo laglo...keep on sharing.
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/19/2009
|
thanks Arnab....
|
|
|
|
K r i s h n e n d u - The NoOne
{K:12059} 6/19/2009
|
anobodyo Anindya-da :)
ki expression chhobitay...bhaba jay na...amar kintu sudhu mukh-ta in focus rakhata master stroke laglo :)
eirokom chhobi dekhe award na deoata anyay :) so alada kore congrats bolbo na..it was very obvious :)
[ekta irrelevant kotha bolchi. amio koyekdin age ekta chhobite BIP peyechi :) jodio in different project...tao bollam karon tomar motamot pele bhalo lagbe. chhobita amar je khub nikhut legeche ta noy. tobe award-ta peye definitely khub bhalo legeche r khuub encouraged hoyechi :) link-ta dichi : http://www.usefilm.com/Image.asp?ID=1527922 ]
|
|
|
|
arnab sarkar
{K:2115} 6/19/2009
|
congrats.. excellent capture.. well deserved honor!
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/19/2009
|
khushi hoini ta bolbo na...aktu content lagche ai ja. Prothom to ;)
out of focus ta steve dar doya ...uni gurudeb 
|
|
|
|
|
soumya
{K:13087} 6/19/2009
|
eito award. ebar khushi to? :-)
chhobi ta bhalo. bachcha tar sorir ta out of focus na hoy in focus hole aaro better lagto.
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/19/2009
|
thanks Atish da.
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/19/2009
|
thanks Avida...etar print nebar ichche ache.
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/19/2009
|
Thanks so much stingRay.
|
|
|
|
|
Anindya Chakraborty
{K:12765} 6/19/2009
|
Thanks Wolf .. :)
|
|
|
|
|
Atish Sen
{K:6346} 6/18/2009
|
very nice
|
|
|
|
|
Avi
{K:70138} 6/18/2009
|
khub bhalo chhobi. it presents the element of uncertainty to the viewer.
|
|
|
|
stingRay pt.4 .
{K:250401} 6/18/2009
|
The dramatic tones are great....possibly questions but I think also a kind of puzzled look. Lovely work Anindya. Best wishes.......Ray
|
|
|
|
Wolf Zorrito
{K:78768} 6/18/2009
|
above her eyes are frownes so ... questions ... :-)
Good expression.
|
|
0 
