I think this one has a lot more impact; the distinctive shapes of the Brooklyn bridge stand out beautifully against the Manhattan skyline.
Maybe it's just me, but it looks like to be a bit hazy, as if the Dynamic range is a bit clipped; also, the sky could maybe use a bit more clarity. Difficult to put my finger on it, so I started fiddling with PS a bit, but couldn't come up with something even remotely stronger...
There seems to be a slightly desaturated spot in the middle of the sky, but that might be this poorly calibrated monitor.
I really like this shot, though; the structures of the Manhattan skyline are definititely a tremendous improvement. Good photo.